Contemporary Issues in the Hotel Industry Marking guide for critiquing a published article Name: 1) Correctly identify explicit and implicit assumptions made. (10 marks) Unable to identify any assumptions made Ability to identify all assumptions made Assumptions identified are incorrect All assumptions identified are correct 2) Ability to challenge the assumptions made. (15 marks) 10 marks No challenge on assumptions made Inadequate challenge on assumptions made Adequate challenge on assumptions made 3) Ability to explain if the reasoning made is logical. (10 marks) Unable to explain any reasoning Partial explanation of reasoning Comprehensive explanation of reasoning 4) Ability to identify evidence presented for assertions. (10 marks) No identification of evidence presented. Partial or unclear identification Complete and clear identification of evidence 5) Explanation if evidence presented is sound. (10 marks) No explanation given Partial explanation given Comprehensive evidence given 6) Explanation of whose interests and what interests are served by the assertions made by author. (15 marks) 0—No explanation of interests served by assertions made Comprehensive explanation of interest served by assertions made Explanation of incorrect assertions made Explanation of correct assertions made 7) Explain the values that underpin the reasoning. (10 marks) 10 marks No explanation of values underpinning the reasoning Comprehensive explanation of values underpinning the reasoning Explanation of incorrect values Explanation of correct values 8) Explain the implications of the conclusion. (10 marks) No explanation of implications of conclusion Partial explanation of implications of conclusion Comprehensive explanation of implications of conclusions 9) Explain if alternative conclusions can be drawn from the evidence. (5 marks) No explanation given Partial explanations given Comprehensive explanations given 10) Explain how generalisable the conclusions are. (5 mark)10 marks No explanation given Partial explanations given Comprehensive explanations given
To get assignment help, please contact to our live chat adviser
